Roth vs. Traditional IRA Calculator: Which IRA is Right for You?

Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) are popular because of their flexibility. Use our calculator to help you choose which one is better for now and for the long term.

Arrow both ways

Unlike employer-sponsored retirement plans, which typically have limitations on investment options and fees, IRAs often have more flexibility, with a broader range of investments. More options can help you reduce fees or better diversify. The challenge for most people is understanding which kind of IRA is most advantageous for them—Roth, Traditional, or some combination of both. The advantages of each can shift over time as tax laws and your income level change, so this is a common periodic question for even advanced investors.

Major Factor in Choosing Your IRA: Household Income

As a baseline, you must earn income in a given year to be eligible to contribute to an IRA. For tax years 2020 and 2021, the maximum contribution that an individual can make to an IRA is the lesser of $6,000 ($7,000 if age 50+), OR your taxable compensation for the year. In other words, if your taxable compensation was only $3,000, then your maximum allowable contribution is $3,000.

Additionally, your income will determine whether you are able to contribute to a Roth IRA, and also whether you are eligible to deduct contributions made to a Traditional IRA. However, the IRS doesn’t use your gross income; they look at your modified adjusted gross income, which can be different from taxable income. With Roth IRAs, your ability to contribute is phased out when your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) reaches a certain level:

  • For married taxpayers who file jointly, the phaseout for 2020 contributions begins at $196,000, and you are completely phased out completely when your MAGI reaches $206,000. For 2021 contributions, the phaseout begins at $198,000, and you are completely phased out completely when your MAGI reaches $208,000.
  • If you are single, the phaseout for 2020 contributions begins at $124,000, and you are completely phased out when your MAGI reaches $139,000. For 2021 contributions, the phaseout begins at $125,000, and you are completely phased out completely when your MAGI reaches $140,000.

For more information, see the IRS overview of IRA contribution limits.

Regardless of how high your income may be, you can always contribute to a Traditional IRA. But your MAGI—along with whether or not you are covered by an employer-sponsored retirement plan—will determine whether or not you are eligible to deduct your Traditional IRA contribution. Check out this IRS resource on IRA deduction limits.

Consider the Tax Benefits

After you have determined the type of IRA for which you’re eligible, you’ll then need to decide which is best for your personal tax situation:

  • Roth IRA: No tax deduction for your contribution; you contribute to the account with after-tax dollars. The money grows tax-free, so when it’s time to withdraw the money in retirement, you don’t have to pay taxes on it.
  • Traditional IRA: Typically receive a tax deduction now (reducing your current income for tax purposes), for the contributions you make. Your money grows tax-deferred, meaning you don’t have to pay taxes until you begin withdrawing money from your account later, when the money is taxed at your marginal rate.

The main question to ask is whether you expect to be in a higher tax bracket than you are now when you withdraw from the account in retirement. If you choose a Roth IRA, you pay taxes now, and if you retire in a higher tax bracket, or if tax rates go up over time, your withdrawals are protected from those increases.

With a Traditional IRA, you save money now—providing you can claim tax deductions. A Traditional IRA is also ideal if you think that your taxes will be lower later. You’ll put off paying your taxes until you are likely to owe less.

Your ability to offset your current tax liability with your Traditional IRA contributions can be limited by your income. Once you reach certain thresholds (which are set based on whether or not you (or your spouse) have access to a retirement plan through an employer), your deduction starts to phase out. Check out this IRS resource on IRA deduction limits.

If you can’t contribute to a Roth IRA due to income restrictions, but also are not able to deduct your Traditional IRA contributions, you might consider making a Traditional IRA contribution and then completing a Roth conversion (otherwise known as a backdoor Roth contribution).  Note that there may be tax consequences from making a Roth conversion, and whether this strategy is right for you depends on your situation.

Getting Started

When you open a a Betterment account, we provide advice (even before you fund) regarding which retirement accounts you should be funding and in what order. You can even sync up your existing IRAs, 401(k)s, and other financial accounts to see an overall picture of your finances. Get started or log in to complete your retirement plan and see personalized savings advice.

Betterment is not a tax advisor, and we don’t provide tax advice as a service, so this information is just for educational purposes. You should consult a qualified tax professional regarding your personal situation.

Any links provided to other server sites are offered as a matter of convenience and are not intended to imply that Betterment or its writers endorse, sponsor, promote, and/or are affiliated with the owners of or participants in those sites, or endorses any information contained on those sites, unless expressly stated otherwise.