Betterment Editors

Inside the investing kitchen, part 1 Jun 24, 2025 11:30:00 AM The recipe for a better portfolio, and the science behind a safer nest egg. Jamie Lee isn’t a Top Chef, but he knows his way around the kitchen. He dabbles in sous vide with the help of a sous chef (his 6-year-old daughter). He loves smoking salmon low and slow on a pair of pellet grills. And in some ways, his day job on the Betterment Investing team resembles the culinary world as well. He and his teammates work in a test kitchen of sorts, defining and refining the recipes for our low-cost, high-performing, and globally-diversified portfolios. They size up ingredients, pair flavors, and thoughtfully assemble the courses of each “meal.” All in service of customers with varying appetites for risk. It's highly-technical work, but we wouldn't be Betterment if we didn't make our methodologies as accessible as possible. So whether you're kicking the tires on our services, or you're already a customer and simply curious about the mechanics of your money machine, come along for a three-part, behind-the-scenes look at how we cook up a better portfolio. Here in part 1, we'll explore how we allocate your investing at a high level. In part 2, we'll zoom in to our process for selecting specific funds. And in part 3, we'll show you how we handle thousands of trades each day to keep our customers’ portfolios in tip-top shape. The science behind a safer nest egg Betterment customers rely on Jamie and team to do the heavy lifting of portfolio construction. They distill handfuls of asset classes, a hundred-plus risk levels, and thousands of funds into a simple yet eclectic menu of investment options. And underpinning much of this process is something called Modern Portfolio Theory, a framework developed by the late American economist Harry Markowitz. The theory revolutionized how investors think about risk, and led to Markowitz winning the Nobel Prize in 1990. Diversification lies at the heart of Modern Portfolio Theory. The more of it your investing has, the theory goes, the less risk you're exposed to. But that barely scratches the surface. One of the meatiest parts of building a portfolio (and by extension, diversifying your investing) is how much weight to give each asset class, also known as asset allocation. Broadly speaking, you have stocks and bonds. But you can slice up the pie in several other ways. There’s large cap companies or less established ones. Government debt or the corporate variety. And even more relevant as of late: American markets or international. Jamie came of age in South Korea during the late 90s. Back here in the States, the dot-com bubble was still years away from popping. But in South Korea and Asia more broadly, a financial crisis was well underway. And it changed the trajectory of Jamie’s career. His interest in and application of math shifted from computer science to the study of markets, and ultimately led to a PhD in statistics. Jamie Lee (right) helps optimize the weights of asset classes in Betterment portfolios. For Jamie, the interplay of markets at a global level is fascinating. So it’s only fitting that when optimizing asset allocations for customers, Jamie and team start with the hypothetical "global market portfolio," an imaginary snapshot of all the investable assets in the world. The current value of U.S. stocks, for example, represents about two-thirds the value of all stocks, so it's weighted accordingly in the global market portfolio. These weights are the jumping off point for a key part of the portfolio construction process: projecting future returns. Reverse engineering expected returns “Past performance does not guarantee future results.” We include this type of language in all of our communications at Betterment, but for quantitative researchers, or “quants,” like Jamie, it’s more than a boilerplate. It’s why our forecasts for the expected returns of various asset classes largely aren't based on historical performance. They're forward-looking. "Past data is simply too unreliable," says Jamie. "Look at the biggest companies of the 90s; that list is completely different from today.” So to build our forecasts, commonly referred to in the investing world as Capital Market Assumptions, we pretend for a moment that the global market portfolio is the optimal one. Since we know roughly how each of those asset classes performs relative to one another, we can reverse engineer their expected returns. This robust math is represented by a deceivingly short equation—μ = λ Σ ωmarket—which you can read more about in our full portfolio construction methodology. From there, we simulate thousands of paths for the market, factoring in both our forecasts and those of large asset managers like BlackRock to find the optimal allocation for each path. Then we average those weights to land on a single recommendation. This “Monte Carlo" style of simulations is commonly used in environments filled with variables. Environments like, say, capital markets. The outputs are the asset allocation percentages (refreshed each year) that you see in the holdings portion of your portfolio details Hypothetical portfolio; for illustration only At this point in the journey, however, our Investing team's work is hardly finished. They still need to seek out some of the most cost-effective, and just plain effective, funds that give you the intended exposure to each relevant asset class. For this, we need to head out of the test kitchen and into the market. So don’t forget your tote bag.

Inside the investing kitchen, part 2 Jun 24, 2025 11:25:00 AM See how we source the higher-quality, lower-cost funds that fill up your portfolio. A lot goes into the making of a single Betterment portfolio. So much that we're spreading out this showcase of our Investing team's work over three parts. In part 1, we explore how we allocate customers’ investing at a high level, and in part 3, we show how we handle thousands of trades each day to keep their portfolios humming. And here in part 2, we zoom into a topic that may be a little more relatable for the everyday investor: picking the actual investments themselves. If asset allocation is like refining a recipe, then today's topic of fund selection is all about the sourcing of higher-quality, lower-cost ingredients. And for that, we turn our eye toward a market of another kind. Josh Shrair specializes in shopping capital markets here at Betterment, picking the funds that fill up your portfolio's respective allocations. His line of work looked a little different decades ago, back when his step dad was working as a trader on Wall Street. Back then, this level of attention to portfolio construction and fund selection was typically in service of only the ultra wealthy. But now, Josh and team navigate a rapidly-expanding universe of investments on behalf of everyday investors. Why shopping for funds isn't always so simple On one hand, the recent explosion of investment options has been great for investors. Increased competition drives down costs and opens up access to newer, more niche markets. But more choice also leads to more complexity. Take Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), our preferred building block for portfolios thanks to their transparency, tax efficiency, and lower costs. They bundle up hundreds, and sometimes thousands, of individual stocks and bonds. But even ETFs are multiplying fast. In 2024 alone, 723 new ones launched, bringing the total to nearly 4,000. To illustrate this abundance, let's say your asset allocation calls for a heaping serving of “Large Cap” stocks, meaning companies valued at $10 billion or more. Nearly 500 ETFs populate this particular corner of the ETF universe. We can narrow that group down to 30 based on the specific exposure we’re looking for, like say U.S. Large Cap companies, or the S&P 500, a list or “index” of 500 of the biggest American companies. But the due diligence is hardly done. Some ETFs that track the S&P 500 follow it faithfully, while others put their own spin on it, which can open investors up to unintended exposure. Josh Shrair (second from left) helps navigate a rapidly-expanding universe of ETFs on behalf of Betterment customers. Just as crucially, their costs are all over the place, and higher fees can erode your returns in the long run. That's why the SPDR fund is currently our Core portfolio’s primary way of achieving U.S. Large Cap stock exposure. It offers both a low cost to hold (0.02%) and a low cost to trade (0.03% at the time of writing), making for a low overall cost of ownership. "Shopping for investments is a little like buying a car," Josh says. "The total cost is way more than the sticker price." How we calculate cost of ownership Part of our role as a fiduciary, someone who's legally obligated to act in their clients' best interests, is conducting a deep and unbiased evaluation of the ETFs used in our portfolios. The process Josh and team use is entirely "open architecture," meaning we’re not obligated to use funds from any particular provider. Instead, we strive to select the most optimal ones in terms of cost and exposure. It helps that Betterment itself doesn't make, manage, and sell funds, which means we avoid the inherent conflict of interest some advisors face when they also act as a fund manager. These firms can be tempted to steer customers toward their own funds, even when a better alternative exists. So we take pride in the due diligence behind our fund selection, and that begins with our "cost of ownership" scoring methodology. It factors in the two types of costs mentioned earlier: the cost to "hold" or own a fund, also known as its expense ratio, and the cost to trade it. As you'll see in part 3 of this series, a portfolio is hardly static. Deposits come in. Withdrawals go out. Rebalancing takes place on the regular. All of this requires daily trading, so the cost of those transactions matters to your investing's bottom line. The cost-to-trade is also known as the "bid-ask spread," or the markup that traders expect when selling a share. It's how they make money, and similar to wholesalers and retailers like Costco, the bigger the fund, the smaller the margins a trader can live with. Seeking out these value buys is how we're able to deliver globally-diversified portfolios at a fraction of the cost of alternatives on the market today. And we’re never done shopping. Our preferred funds are updated multiple times throughout the year. Primed for the purchase There's a lot more to our fund selection methodology, especially for funds that aren’t tied to a specific index, but are instead made from scratch. Some fund managers like Goldman Sachs, where Josh worked earlier in his career, also blend both approaches into a “smart beta” strategy. We offer one such portfolio alongside our Betterment-built collections. But for the sake of this series, let's pretend for a moment that our tote bags are full, and we're ready to check out. It’s time to meet the team behind every transaction at Betterment.

Inside the investing kitchen, part 3 Jun 24, 2025 11:16:45 AM Order up! See how we handle thousands of trades each day to keep customers’ portfolios humming. When a chef plates a meal, they typically send it off, never to be seen again. But serving up an investing portfolio is an ongoing affair. Deposits come in. Withdrawals go out. Asset classes grow and shrink as the market moves. Rebalancing takes place on the regular. All of this requires daily trading. And this buying and selling of securities is among the most intricate and highly-regulated pieces of our operations. So while the first two parts of this series cover the recipes and ingredients behind our investing, our final course focuses on the team—and tech—behind every transaction. What happens when you hit "deposit" Cara Daly is an adventurer at heart. An avid surfer and the daughter of a flight attendant, she racks up air miles chasing waves and visiting family in Ireland. So naturally, she's gravitated toward one of the more thrill-seeking roles on our Investing team: Capital Markets. From the minute markets open each day, Cara and team monitor the action, making sure our customers' orders go smoothly. These trades can amount to hundreds of millions of dollars in a single day, and the system that executes them all is in many ways our secret sauce. It's custom-built (a rarity in the industry) and plays the role of Mission Control. When a customer clicks "deposit," for example, that single click gets translated into a series of purchases. These in turn get bundled up with other purchases of a like-kind and turned into orders, which are then executed at calibrated intervals as a part of our managed trading strategy. This sort of intentional trading is incredibly important because of the scale of our operations. We manage more than $56 billion of assets, making us the largest independent robo-advisor out there. We may not "make" markets, but our trading volume is big enough to potentially influence them. So we need to be mindful of how and when our trades get executed. “Say the market trades $10 million of a hypothetical security on any given day,” Cara says. “If our customers happen to want $20 million of it, meeting all that demand without minding the bigger context could drive up the price.” To navigate these executional challenges, we deploy multiple strategies as needed (see below for a few examples), evaluating and calibrating each on a continuous basis. Taken altogether, they help ensure our customers' purchases and sales get treated fairly in the market. Waiting out the first half hour after markets open before starting our trading. This helps sidestep some of the volatility that's common early in the day. Trading periodically throughout the day, and randomizing when customers’ orders are processed. It's possible that prices can loosely correlate with certain times of the day, so we don't want that to consistently affect any one customer. Briefly holding back on “system-generated” trading (proactive rebalancing, for example) for any particular fund if its trading reaches a certain threshold relative to its average daily volume. This helps make sure “user-directed” trading (when customers make deposits or withdrawals, to name a few examples) can continue regardless. Partnering with industry experts like Apex to route and execute orders across multiple firms, helping us stay at the forefront of the evolving market landscape. This access to different execution venues also helps seek out the most favorable terms for customers—whether that’s price, speed, or overall execution quality. Switching gears from execution to tax optimization, we also use both primary and secondary funds for most of our asset classes. These backup “tickers” come into play during times of heightened volatility in markets. Moments that can make or break an investing strategy. Acing the stress test of market volatility More often than not, it's business as usual on our Capital Markets team, and that's by design. But during stretches of extreme volatility, when trading volume really picks up and prices can swing wildly from hour to hour, it's all hands on deck. Cara and company monitor our trading system for signs that additional oversight may be needed. They ease emerging bottlenecks in real time and keep things running smoothly, at times enlisting the support of our Trading Engineering team. Cara Daly (left) helps make sure customers’ daily trading goes smoothly. Take April of 2025 for example. Early in the month, the Trump administration caught investors off guard by announcing a series of tariffs way higher and way earlier than expected. The announcement, and the inconsistent messaging that followed, set off a wild, weeks-long stretch of trading. Prices of some securities cratered in the morning only to recover by day's end. Our systems not only weathered this storm, but capitalized on it, taking advantage of small windows of time to harvest tens of millions of dollars in temporary losses for customers before prices recovered. This strategy of tax loss harvesting helps sprinkle tax advantages on a portion of customers' taxable investing, and it wouldn’t be possible without the help of those aforementioned secondary tickers. These funds help avoid “wash sales” while maintaining customers’ desired exposures and risk levels. Something delicious is simmering The image of a golden harvest is an apt one, considering this series looks at our Investing team's work through a culinary lens. Many of our customers come to us not necessarily for a single serving of returns, but to plant the seeds for self-sustaining, long-term wealth. A harvest that supports a more-fulfilling life. Cara and the rest of our Capital Markets experts are a big part of that lifecycle, tending to thousands of daily trades that optimize our customers’ portfolios over and over again. That's the beauty of using technology as a tool to expand our own capabilities and deliver results at scale. It's a people-led process. We became a trusted leader in automated money management not because of our tech, but because of the people who build and use it each day. Specialists like Cara, Josh, and Jamie—They're our secret ingredient, working in service of customers hungry for a better way to invest. Bon appétit.

Four ways we help trim your tax bill Jun 9, 2025 7:00:00 AM And why these "invisible" wins matter more than you may think. As investors, we tend to focus most on what we can see. Things like portfolio makeup, and the returns generated by those investments. No less important, however, are the less obvious things, like the taxes you never paid in the first place because of technology that quietly runs in the background. You may only think about taxes once a year, but here at Betterment, every day is Tax Day. This sort of year-round tax optimization sounds boring, but believe us, it makes a difference. Taxes can steadily eat away at your returns over the years. So any advisor worth their salt should take taxes seriously and minimize them as much as possible. These “invisible” wins are hard to spot in the moment, so let’s shine a light on them now. Here are four sophisticated ways we buy, sell, and hold your shares, all in the name of trimming your tax bill. Choosing which assets go where – Our Tax Coordination feature helps shield high-growth assets in the most tax-efficient account types. Rebalancing wisely – We take advantage of any existing cash flows to help minimize capital gains taxes while rebalancing your portfolio. Choosing which taxable shares to sell (or donate) – Our TaxMin technology helps minimize short-term capital gains taxes. Harvesting losses – When your taxable investments dip below their initial purchase price, we jump on the opportunity to “harvest” the theoretical loss and potentially lower your future tax bill. 1. Choosing which assets go where From a tax perspective, you have three main account types at your disposal when saving for retirement: Tax-deferred (traditional IRAs, 401(k)s, etc.), where taxes are paid later. Tax-exempt (Roth IRAs, 401(k)s, etc.), where taxes are paid now. Taxable, where taxes are paid both now and later. Because of their different tax treatments, certain types of investments are a better fit for certain accounts. Interest from bonds, for example, is typically taxed at a higher rate than stocks, so it often makes sense to keep them away from taxable accounts. This sorting of asset types based on tax treatments, rather than divvying them up equally across accounts, is known as asset location. And our fully-automated, mathematically-rigorous spin on it is called Tax Coordination. When Tax Coordination is turned on, the net effect is more of your portfolio's growth is shielded in a Roth account, the pot of money you crucially don't pay taxes on when withdrawing funds. To learn more about our Tax Coordination feature and whether it’s right for you, take a peek at its disclosure. 2. Rebalancing wisely When the weights of asset classes in your portfolio drift too far from their targets, our technology automatically brings them back into balance. But there's more than one way to accomplish this portfolio rebalancing. You can simply sell some of the assets that are overweight, and buy the ones that are underweight (aka "sell/buy" rebalancing), but that can realize capital gains and result in more taxes owed. So we first take advantage of any available cash flows coming into or out of your portfolio. When you make a withdrawal, for example, we intentionally liquidate overweight assets while striving to minimize your tax hit as much as possible (more on that below). And when you deposit money or receive dividends, we use those funds to beef up underweight assets. 3. Choosing which taxable shares to sell (or donate) Say there's no way around it: you need to sell an asset. Maybe cash flows aren't enough to keep your portfolio completely balanced. Or you’re withdrawing funds for a major purchase. The question then becomes: which specific assets should be sold? The IRS and many brokers follow the simple script of "first in, first out," meaning your oldest assets are sold first. This approach is easier for your broker, and it can avoid more highly-taxed short-term capital gains. But it often misses the opportunity of selling assets at a loss, and harvesting those losses for potential tax benefits. So our algorithms take a more nuanced approach to selecting shares, and we call this technology TaxMin. TaxMin is calibrated to avoid frequent small rebalance transactions and seek tax-efficient outcomes, things like avoiding wash sales and minimizing short-term capital gains. In the case of donating shares, we apply the same logic in reverse, or TaxMax as we call it. That's because when donating shares, it benefits you to choose the ones with the most gains, since any shares bought as a replacement will effectively have a reset tax bill. 4. Harvesting losses Life is full of ups and downs, and your investments are no different. At times, most notably during market downturns, the price of an asset may dip below what you paid for it. Tax loss harvesting takes advantage of these moments, selling taxable assets that fit this bill, then replacing them with similar ones so you stay invested. You can then use those harvested losses to shift taxes you owe now into the future. The strategy doesn’t make sense for everyone, but it can help some investors sprinkle tax advantages on a portion of their taxable investing. And our fully-automated spin on it takes a tax hack once reserved for the wealthy and makes it available to the masses. Happy harvesting. In conclusion, we care a lot about taxes Because it’s one of the most reliable ways to boost your returns. We can’t control the market, but tax laws? Those are set by the IRS and broadcast far and wide. And we can help you navigate them wisely. We wouldn’t be doing our job if we didn’t. So the next time you take a peek at your returns, ask yourself how much of that growth will still be there come tax time. If you’re a Betterment customer, you can rest assured we’re working tirelessly to minimize those tax drags. You may not realize it right away, and rightfully so. Live your life, and leave the tax toiling to us.

How to course correct when you simply can't stay the course May 12, 2025 3:20:36 PM De-risking during market volatility can be costly. Here’s how to do it without breaking the bank. The best course of action during market volatility is often inaction. That’s because selling riskier assets at a loss locks in those losses. It foregoes their potential for future growth, and it might also trigger capital gains taxes in the process. But if taking some sort of action feels necessary, then modestly reducing your overall risk exposure can be a reasonable alternative. Consider dialing down your existing stock allocation by a few percentage points, or lower the costs of recalibrating by using your future deposits instead. Either way, the solution may be the same: sprinkling in more bonds. Consider bonds to calm your investing nerves When people talk about diversification, equities like international stocks get most of the attention. But no less important in the role of managing risk are bonds. These are the loans given to governments and companies by investors, and while they're not completely risk-free (no asset is), the relatively-modest interest they tend to pay out can feel like a windfall when stock values are plunging. They won’t negate all of the volatility of stocks, but they can help smooth things out and preserve capital. This is why all of our recommended allocations include holding at least some bonds. One way to de-risk some of your future investing is with one of our portfolios made up of both stocks and bonds (Core, Value Tilt, etc.). We’ll recommend a risk level based on your goal, but we make it easy to dial up the bond allocation to your preference. Over time, you can slowly finetune things until your collective risk feels right. Or you can let us automatically adjust it based on your target date. We also offer two portfolios comprised entirely of bonds, each one designed for a different use: The BlackRock Target Income portfolio, designed to help you limit market volatility, preserve wealth, and generate income. The Goldman Sachs Tax-Smart Bonds portfolio, designed for high-income individuals seeking a higher after-tax yield compared to a cash account. Don’t forget about the role of cash One of the best ways to mitigate your overall financial risk is by shoring up your emergency fund, which may include a high-yield cash account like our Cash Reserve. Imagine losing your income stream, and how much time you'd want to get back on your feet. A good place to start is 3-6 months' worth of your essential expenses, but your right amount is whatever helps you sleep more soundly at night. Steadying the ship during unsteady times As we mentioned up front, right-sizing your risk during downturns isn’t always cheap. But there are ways to minimize the costs. Lowering your risk profile incrementally is one of them, and stretching out your safety net is another. Either way, it’s okay to recalibrate your risk tolerance from time-to-time, and you can do it wisely with Betterment.

How tax loss harvesting turns market losses into tax wins Apr 28, 2025 6:00:00 AM The tax strategy can unlock similar benefits as tax-deferred accounts Tax loss harvesting, or TLH for short, is selling an asset at a loss (which can happen especially during market downturns) primarily to offset taxes owed on capital gains or income. It shifts some of the taxes you might owe now, in other words, into the future. But the key takeaway is this: TLH can take a portion of your taxable investing and effectively turn it into tax-deferred investing. And tax-deferred investing, as we’ll quickly demonstrate, can do wonders for wealth-building. Tax me now or tax me later Take a dollar you would’ve otherwise paid in taxes today. Now invest it wisely. Odds are, it’ll be worth a lot more in the long run, even taking away any taxes you eventually owe. Depending on how your tax situation shakes out over the years, tax-deferred investing can be like Uncle Sam giving you a nearly interest-free loan to invest. This is in large part why tax-deferred accounts like traditional 401(k)s and IRAs come with restrictions. They’re reserved for retirement, namely, and their contributions are capped. But tax loss harvesting opens an entirely new door for tax-deferred investing, along with a few other side benefits. For a few types of investors in particular, it offers tremendous upside. Who TLH benefits the most Let’s start with an important caveat: While TLH offers potential value for most investors, it can be a wash or actually increase your tax burden in certain cases. But for now, let’s focus on three types of investors who can reap some of the biggest rewards from the strategy: The high-income earner Once you’ve offset all of your realized capital gains taxes for a given year, any leftover harvested losses can be used to offset taxes on up to $3,000 of ordinary income. So in the case of high earners, this means trading a high income tax rate for a relatively low long-term capital gains tax rate. The end result is both deferring and discounting your taxes. The steady saver Not only are recurring deposits a great way to start a savings habit, they also produce more harvesting opportunities. That’s because the older an investment, the less likely it drops below its initial purchase price (aka “cost basis”) and can be harvested at a loss. A steady drip of deposits, monthly for example, creates fresh crops of investments for harvesting in the near future. The tax-smart philanthropist A common misconception of tax loss harvesting is that it helps you avoid paying taxes altogether. Believe it or not, however, two scenarios exist in which you actually can cancel out your tax obligation: The first is when you donate shares to charity. As we mentioned earlier, selling and replacing shares as part of a harvest increases their future tax bill. It does this by lowering the shares’ cost basis, or the initial purchase price used to calculate capital gains. If you donate and replace these shares down the road, however, you reset their cost basis to a new, higher level. This effectively wipes out their entire tax bill(!) that had accrued to that point. In the eyes of the IRS, it’s like those capital gains never happened, and it’s one big reason why wealthy investors have long paired TLH with the practice of donating shares. The second scenario is posthumously. At that point, you won’t get a tax break, of course. But any individuals who you leave shares to will, because immediately after your death, the cost basis of your investments similarly “steps up” to their current market value. Your harvest awaits Historically-speaking, tax loss harvesting has been too time-intensive and costly to execute for all but the wealthiest of investors. But technology like ours and the low-cost trading of ETFs have made it a tax strategy for the masses. Take the market volatility of 2025 as an example. In little more than two weeks (March 26-April 10), Betterment harvested nearly $60 million in tax losses for customers. If TLH is right for you, the sooner you open and start contributing to a taxable account, the sooner you can start giving a portion of your taxable investing an edge. If you already have a Betterment taxable account, here’s how to turn on tax loss harvesting.

Our Socially Responsible Investing portfolios methodology Mar 31, 2025 7:00:00 AM Learn how we construct our Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) portfolios. Table of Contents Introduction How do we define SRI? The Challenges of SRI Portfolio Construction How is Betterment’s Broad Impact portfolio constructed? How is Betterment’s Climate Impact portfolio constructed? How is Betterment’s Social Impact portfolio constructed? Conclusion Introduction Betterment launched its first Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) portfolio in 2017, and has widened the investment options under that umbrella since then. Within Betterment’s SRI options, we currently offer a Broad Impact portfolio and two additional, more focused SRI portfolio options: a Social Impact SRI portfolio (focused on social empowerment) and a Climate Impact SRI portfolio (focused on climate-conscious investments). These portfolios represent a diversified, relatively low-cost solution constructed using exchange traded funds (ETFs), which will be continually improved upon as costs decline, more data emerges, and as a result, the availability of SRI funds broadens. How do we define SRI? Our approach to SRI has three fundamental dimensions that shape our portfolio construction mandates: Reducing exposure to investments involved in unsustainable activities and environmental, social, or governmental controversies. Increasing exposure to investments that work to address solutions for core environmental and social challenges in measurable ways. Allocating to investments that use shareholder engagement tools, such as shareholder proposals and proxy voting, to incentivize socially responsible corporate behavior. SRI is the traditional name for the broad concept of values-driven investing (many experts now favor “sustainable investing” as the name for the entire category). Our SRI approach uses SRI mandates based on a set of industry criteria known as “ESG,” which stands for Environmental, Social and Governance. ESG refers specifically to the quantifiable dimensions of a company’s standing along each of its three components. Betterment’s approach expands upon the ESG-investing framework with exposure to investments that use complementary shareholder engagement tools. Betterment does not directly select companies to include in, or exclude from, the SRI portfolios. Rather, Betterment identifies ETFs that have been classified as ESG or similar by third-parties and considers internally developed “SRI mandates” alongside other qualitative and quantitative factors to select ETFs to include in its SRI portfolios. Using SRI Mandates One aspect of improving a portfolio’s ESG exposure is reducing exposure to companies that engage in certain activities that may be considered undesirable because they do not align with specific values. These activities may include selling tobacco, military weapons, civilian firearms, as well as involvement in recent and ongoing ESG controversies. However, SRI is about more than just adjusting your portfolio to minimize companies with a poor social impact. For each Betterment SRI portfolio, the portfolio construction process considers one or more internally developed “SRI mandates.” Betterment’s SRI mandates are sustainable investing objectives that we include in our portfolios’ exposures. SRI Mandate Description Betterment SRI Portfolio Mapping ESG Mandate ETFs tracking indices which are constructed with reference to some form of ESG optimization, which promotes exposure to Environmental, Social, and Governance pillars. Broad, Climate, Social Impact Portfolios Fossil Fuel Divestment Mandate ETFs tracking indices which are constructed with the aim of excluding stocks in companies with major fossil fuels holdings (divestment). Climate Impact Portfolio Carbon Footprint Mandate ETFs tracking indices which are constructed with the aim of minimizing exposure to carbon emissions across the entire economy (rather than focus on screening out exposure to stocks primarily in the energy sector). Climate Impact Portfolio Green Financing Mandates ETFs tracking indices focused on financing environmentally beneficial activities directly. Climate Impact Portfolio Gender Equity Mandate ETFs tracking indices which are constructed with the aim of representing the performance of companies that seek to advance gender equality. Social Impact Portfolio Social Equity Mandate ETFs managed with the aim of obtaining exposures in investments that seek to advance vulnerable, disadvantaged, or underserved social groups. The Gender Equity Mandate also contributes to fulfilling this broader mandate. Social Impact Portfolio Shareholder Engagement Mandate In addition to the mandates listed above, Betterment’s SRI portfolios are constructed using a shareholder engagement mandate. One of the most direct ways a shareholder can influence a company’s decision making is through shareholder proposals and proxy voting. Publicly traded companies have annual meetings where they report on the business’s activities to shareholders. As a part of these meetings, shareholders can vote on a number of topics such as share ownership, the composition of the board of directors, and executive level compensation. Shareholders receive information on the topics to be voted on prior to the meeting in the form of a proxy statement, and can vote on these topics through a proxy card. A shareholder can also make an explicit recommendation for the company to take a specific course of action through a shareholder proposal. ETF shareholders themselves do not vote in the proxy voting process of underlying companies, but rather the ETF fund issuer participates in the proxy voting process on behalf of their shareholders. As investors signal increasing interest in ESG engagement, more ETF fund issuers have emerged that play a more active role engaging with underlying companies through proxy voting to advocate for more socially responsible corporate practices. These issuers use engagement-based strategies, such as shareholder proposals and director nominees, to engage with companies to bring about ESG change and allow investors in the ETF to express a socially responsible preference. For this reason, Betterment includes a Shareholder Engagement Mandate in its SRI portfolios. Mandate Description Betterment SRI Portfolio Mapping Shareholder Engagement Mandate ETFs which aim to fulfill one or more of the above mandates, not via allocation decisions, but rather through the shareholder engagement process, such as proxy voting. Broad, Climate, Social Impact Portfolios The Challenges of SRI Portfolio Construction For Betterment, three limitations have a large influence on our overall approach to building an SRI portfolio: 1. Many existing SRI offerings in the market have serious shortcomings. Many SRI offerings today sacrifice sufficient diversification appropriate for investors who seek market returns, and/or do not provide investors an avenue to use collective action to bring about ESG change. Betterment’s SRI portfolios do not sacrifice global diversification. Consistent with our core principle of global diversification and to ensure both domestic and international bond exposure, we’re still allocating to some funds without an ESG mandate, until satisfactory solutions are available within those asset classes. Additionally, all three of Betterment’s SRI portfolios include a partial allocation to an engagement-based socially responsible ETF using shareholder advocacy as a means to bring about ESG-change in corporate behavior. Engagement-based socially responsible ETFs have expressive value in that they allow investors to signal their interest in ESG issues to companies and the market more broadly, even if particular shareholder campaigns are unsuccessful. 2. Integrating values into an ETF portfolio may not always meet every investor’s expectations. For investors who prioritize an absolute exclusion of specific types of companies above all else, certain approaches to ESG will inevitably fall short of expectations. For example, many of the largest ESG funds focused on US Large Cap stocks include some energy companies that engage in oil and natural gas exploration, like Hess. While Hess might not meet the criteria of the “E” pillar of ESG, it could still meet the criteria in terms of the “S” and the “G.” Understanding that investors may prefer to focus specifically on a certain pillar of ESG, Betterment has made three SRI portfolios available. The Broad Impact portfolio seeks to balance each of the three dimensions of ESG without diluting different dimensions of social responsibility. With our Social Impact portfolio, we sharpen the focus on social equity with partial allocations to gender diversity and veteran impact focused funds. With our Climate Impact portfolio, we sharpen the focus on controlling carbon emissions and fostering green solutions. 3. Most available SRI-oriented ETFs present liquidity limitations. While SRI-oriented ETFs have relatively low expense ratios compared to SRI mutual funds, our analysis revealed insufficient liquidity in many ETFs currently on the market. Without sufficient liquidity, every execution becomes more expensive, creating a drag on returns. Median daily dollar volume is one way of estimating liquidity. Higher volume on a given asset means that you can quickly buy (or sell) more of that asset in the market without driving the price up (or down). The degree to which you can drive the price up or down with your buying or selling must be treated as a cost that can drag down on your returns. To that end, Betterment reassesses the funds available for inclusion in these portfolios regularly. In balancing cost and value for the portfolios, the options are limited to funds of certain asset classes such as US stocks, Developed Market stocks, Emerging Market stocks, US Investment Grade Corporate Bonds, US High Quality bonds, and US Mortgage-Backed Securities. How is Betterment’s Broad Impact portfolio constructed? Betterment’s Broad Impact portfolio invests assets in socially responsible ETFs to obtain exposure to both the ESG and Shareholder Engagement mandates, as highlighted in the table above. It focuses on ETFs that consider all three ESG pillars, and includes an allocation to an engagement-based SRI ETF. Broad ESG investing solutions are currently the most liquid, highlighting their popularity amongst investors. In order to maintain geographic and asset class diversification and to meet our requirements for lower cost and higher liquidity in all SRI portfolios, we continue to allocate to some funds that do not reflect SRI mandates, particularly in bond asset classes. How is Betterment’s Climate Impact portfolio constructed? Betterment offers a Climate Impact portfolio for investors that want to invest in an SRI strategy more focused on the environmental pillar of “ESG” rather than focusing on all ESG dimensions equally. Betterment’s Climate Impact portfolio invests assets in socially responsible ETFs and is constructed using the following mandates that seek to achieve divestment and engagement: ESG, carbon footprint reduction, fossil fuel divestment, shareholder engagement, and green financing. The Climate Impact portfolio was designed to give investors exposure to climate-conscious investments, without sacrificing proper diversification and balanced cost. Fund selection for this portfolio follows the same guidelines established for the Broad Impact portfolio, as we seek to incorporate broad based climate-focused ETFs with sufficient liquidity relative to their size in the portfolio. How can the Climate Impact portfolio help to positively affect climate change? The Climate Impact portfolio is allocated to iShares MSCI ACWI Low Carbon Target ETF (CRBN), an ETF which seeks to track the global stock market, but with a bias towards companies with a lower carbon footprint. By investing in CRBN, investors are actively supporting companies with a lower carbon footprint, because CRBN overweights these stocks relative to their high-carbon emitting peers. One way we can measure the carbon impact a fund has is by looking at its weighted average carbon intensity, which measures the weighted average of tons of CO2 emissions per million dollars in sales, based on the fund's underlying holdings. Based on weighted average carbon intensity data from MSCI, Betterment’s 100% stock Climate Impact portfolio has carbon emissions per unit sales that are more than 47% lower than Betterment’s 100% stock Core portfolio as of March 12, 2025. Additionally, a portion of the Climate Impact portfolio is allocated to fossil fuel reserve funds. Rather than ranking and weighting funds based on a certain climate metric like CRBN, fossil fuel reserve free funds instead exclude companies that own fossil fuel reserves, defined as crude oil, natural gas, and thermal coal. By investing in fossil fuel reserve free funds, investors are actively divesting from companies with some of the most negative impact on climate change, including oil producers, refineries, and coal miners such as Chevron, ExxonMobile, BP, and Peabody Energy. Another way that the Climate Impact portfolio promotes a positive environmental impact is by investing in bonds that fund green projects. The Climate Impact portfolio invests in iShares Global Green Bond ETF (BGRN), which tracks the global market of investment-grade bonds linked to environmentally beneficial projects, as determined by MSCI. These bonds are called “green bonds.” The green bonds held by BGRN fund projects in a number of environmental categories defined by MSCI including alternative energy, energy efficiency, pollution prevention and control, sustainable water, green building, and climate adaptation. How is Betterment’s Social Impact portfolio constructed? Betterment offers a Social Impact portfolio for investors that want to invest in a strategy more focused on the social pillar of ESG investing (the S in ESG). Betterment’s Social Impact portfolio invests assets in socially responsible ETFs and is constructed using the following mandates: ESG, gender equity, social equity, and shareholder engagement. The Social Impact portfolio was designed to give investors exposure to investments which promote social empowerment without sacrificing proper diversification and balanced cost. Fund selection for this portfolio follows the same guidelines established for the Broad Impact portfolio discussed above, as we seek to incorporate broad based ETFs that focus on social empowerment with sufficient liquidity relative to their size in the portfolio. How does the Social Impact portfolio help promote social empowerment? The Social Impact portfolio shares many of the same holdings as Betterment’s Broad Impact portfolio. The Social Impact portfolio additionally looks to further promote the “social” pillar of ESG investing by allocating to the following ETFs: SPDR SSGA Gender Diversity Index ETF (SHE) Academy Veteran Impact ETF(VETZ) Goldman Sachs JUST U.S. Large Cap Equity ETF (JUST) SHE is a US Stock ETF that allows investors to invest in more female-led companies compared to the broader market. In order to achieve this objective, companies are ranked within each sector according to their ratio of women in senior leadership positions. Only companies that rank highly within each sector are eligible for inclusion in the fund. By investing in SHE, investors are allocating more of their money to companies that have demonstrated greater gender diversity within senior leadership than other firms in their sector. VETZ, the Academy Veteran Impact ETF, is a US Bond ETF and is the first publicly traded ETF to primarily invest in loans to U.S. service members, military veterans, their survivors, and veteran-owned businesses. A majority of the underlying assets consist of loans to veterans or their families. The fund primarily invests in Mortgage-Backed Securities that are guaranteed by government-sponsored enterprises, such as Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac. The fund also invests in pools of small business loans backed by the Small Business Administration (SBA). JUST, Goldman Sachs JUST U.S. Large Cap Equity ETF, invests in U.S. companies promoting positive change on key social issues, such as worker wellbeing, customer privacy, environmental impact, and community strength, based on the values of the American public as identified by JUST Capital’s polling. Investment in socially responsible ETFs varies by portfolio allocation; not all allocations include the specific ETFs listed above. For more information about these social impact ETFs, including any associated risks, please see our disclosures. Should we expect any difference in an SRI portfolio’s performance? One might expect that a socially responsible portfolio could lead to lower returns in the long term compared to another, similar portfolio. The notion behind this reasoning is that somehow there is a premium to be paid for investing based on your social ideals and values. A white paper written in partnership between Rockefeller Asset Management and NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business studied 1,000+ research papers published from 2015 to 2020 analyzing the relationship between ESG investing and performance. The primary takeaway from this research was that they found “positive correlations between ESG performance and operational efficiencies, stock performance, and lower cost of capital.” When ESG factors were considered in the study, there seemed to be improved performance potential over longer time periods and potential to also provide downside protection during periods of crisis. It’s important to note that performance in the SRI portfolios can be impacted by several variables, and is not guaranteed to align with the results of this study. Dividend Yields Could Be Lower Using the SRI Broad Impact portfolio for reference, dividend yields over a one-year period ending March 31, 2025 indicate that SRI income returns at certain risk levels have been lower than those of the Core portfolio. Oil and gas companies like BP, Chevron, and Exxon, for example, currently have relatively high dividend yields, and excluding them from a given portfolio can cause its income return to be lower. Of course, future dividend yields are uncertain variables and past data may not provide accurate forecasts. Nevertheless, lower dividend yields can be a factor in driving total returns for SRI portfolios to be lower than those of Core portfolios. Comparison of Dividend Yields Source: Bloomberg, Calculations by Betterment for one year period ending March 31, 2025. Dividend yields for each portfolio are calculated using the dividend yields of the primary ETFs used for taxable allocations of Betterment’s portfolios as of March 2025. Conclusion Despite the various limitations that all SRI implementations face today, Betterment will continue to support its customers in further aligning their values to their investments. Betterment may add additional socially responsible funds to the SRI portfolios and replace other ETFs as the investing landscape continues to evolve.

Making sense of market volatility Mar 25, 2025 7:00:00 AM During times of market turbulence, it may be tempting to move your money to safer ground. But it’s important to consider the long-term impact of your decisions. As we've seen recently, the stock market can experience significant fluctuations, rising one day and declining the next. With market swings, tariff announcements, and policy changes flying about, you may be wondering what to do and whether now is the time to take action. You’ll hear from many financial advisors, including Betterment, that volatility is natural and often something you simply need to ride out. Which is true. While the temptation to move your money to safer ground is understandable, it’s important to consider the long-term impact of your decisions. You could miss out on growth opportunities or trigger a larger tax bill. Instead of taking immediate action, take a moment to think through your investing strategy, your financial needs, and potential next steps. Start with this question: When will I need my money? It’s impossible to time the market perfectly. But having a clear timeline for your financial goals allows you to prepare for volatile moments and even take advantage of them. A longer time horizon means you can afford to ride out downturns, while a shorter one may require different considerations. We’ll walk through four different scenarios based on time horizon and how you can align your volatility strategy with your financial goals. Staying invested at every stage in life If you’re not yet in the market: Waiting for the “perfect” time to invest often leads to missed opportunities. The best time to start is now, with a diversified portfolio that aligns with your goals. If you don’t need the money for decades: Whether we’re talking retirement, education savings, or just a healthy investing portfolio, if you’ve got decades to go, time is your greatest asset. Market volatility is normal, even if it feels chaotic. Staying invested and making consistent contributions over time will allow you to benefit from long-term growth and compounding. If you need the money in the next five to 10 years: Your investments still have time to recover from a downturn, but start thinking ahead. Make sure your portfolio reflects your risk tolerance while maintaining a focus on growth. As you get closer to your end goal, you may want to plan to shift toward a more conservative allocation of stocks to bonds, or even move money into a high-yield cash account. If you’re retired or nearly retired: In this retirement-specific case, you’re already drawing down on your investments (or will soon begin to). Remember that even though you’re “using” this money, you’ll be retired for a while, so you don’t want to miss out on growth entirely. “Have a plan that includes a mix of safe and growth-oriented investments. A cash or bond ‘bucket’ can cover short-term needs, while equities can support long-term growth,” says Betterment financial planner, Corbin Blackwell, CFP®. How Betterment can help you mitigate volatility While you can’t avoid market volatility altogether, you can take proactive steps to manage your money and financial needs during market downturns. Establishing a thoughtful investing strategy now will pay dividends in the future. Here are three things to consider as you determine your approach: Invest in a well-diversified portfolio: By investing in a diversified portfolio, your money isn’t riding the wave of any individual stock, asset type, or even a country’s performance. For example, the Betterment Core portfolio is globally diversified and has delivered 9.0% annual returns (after fees) since inception.1 Consider enabling tax loss harvesting: One silver lining strategy during market downturns is tax loss harvesting—a tax-saving tool that Betterment automates. TLH is the process of selling an asset at a loss (which can happen especially during market downturns) primarily to offset taxes owed on capital gains or income. Build and maintain an emergency fund: You should work to maintain 3-6 months of expenses. These funds should be stored in an account that’s relatively liquid but still can provide some level of growth to help keep up with inflation. Depending on your preferences for risk, growth, and liquidity, we offer a few options: Emergency Fund, our investment allocation built specifically for this use case, with 30% stocks and 70% bonds BlackRock Target Income, our 100% bond portfolios Cash Reserve, our 100% high-yield cash account The big picture If you remember nothing else, remember this: The most important thing you can do is avoid making rash decisions based on short-term market movement. Betterment is here with you every step of the way, helping ensure you make the most of your money, whether the market’s up or down. 1As of 12/31/2024, and inception date 9/7/2011. Composite annual time-weighted returns: 12.7% over 1 year, 7.9% over 5 years, and 7.8% over 10 years. Composite performance calculated based on the dollar-weighted average of actual client time-weighted returns for the Core portfolio at 90/10 allocation, net of fees, includes dividend reinvestment, and excludes the impact of cash flows. Past performance not guaranteed, investing involves risk.