Heard about the new way to boost your retirement savings?
While it’s true that these accounts do offer tax advantages—and you can even build up your savings to spend in retirement—HSAs don’t operate the way traditional retirement plans do.
To really leverage the benefits of these accounts, it’s best to max out your 401k and IRA first, and use an HSA as it was intended, i.e. for medical expenses. Here’s why.
The HSA loophole
HSAs aren’t technically retirement plans, but they are trusteed like Individual Retirement Accounts under IRS rules, says Paul Fronstin, director of health research at the Employee Benefits Research Institute. So although an HSA’s primary role is to serve as savings account to offset the cost of high-deductible health plans, you can deposit pre-tax dollars (or deduct your contributions), and the money grows tax-free—similar to an IRA or 401k. You can learn more by reading IRS Publication 969.
If your health plan’s deductible is at least $1,250 ($2,500 for a family), you can open an HSA and contribute up to $3,250 per year for an individual, or $6,450 per family per year. As with an IRA, there’s also a “catch-up provision” that allows you to stash an extra $1,000 a year if you’re 55 or older.
The triple tax-free benefit
So what’s with all the hype?
- Unlike Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs), you can roll over HSA funds from year to year. There’s no “use it or lose it” clause.
- Depending on where you set up your HSA, you’re not limited to keeping it in cash; some companies offer a menu of mutual funds or other investments.
- While your 401k is tied to your employer, your HSA is not. As long as your health plan meets the deductible requirement and permits you to open an HSA, you can open one anywhere, so you can (and should) shop around.
- You can withdraw the funds tax-free at any time for qualified medical expenses.
After age 65, you can withdraw money to pay for non-medical expenses, but the funds will be taxed as income (similar to an IRA). Prior to age 65, you’ll get hit with a 20% penalty on withdrawals for non-medical expenses (and you’ll also owe taxes).
So if you use your HSA funds only for qualified medical expenses, you can net a triple tax break: You get the pre-tax benefits of an IRA; the tax-free withdrawal benefits of a Roth; and the tax-free growth benefits of both. Otherwise, after age 65 you can spend the money on anything, but that money would be taxed, similar to IRA withdrawals.
And there are other considerations.
In terms of HSAs and retirement, these accounts haven’t received the same level of scrutiny and oversight as more traditional plans. For example:
Check your costs. While new regulations now require 401ks to be more transparent about various account and investing fees, HSAs aren’t subject to those rules, says Kevin McKechnie, executive director of the HSA Council with the American Bankers Association. It’s important to ask to see a full schedule of fees and charges when you’re shopping around for the right HSA account.
Depending on the provider, you could be charged a monthly account fee, a check-writing fee or other transaction fees, notes Fronstin.
Know what you’re getting. It’s crucial to understand the options your HSA provider is offering because they vary widely.
One company, Health Savings Administrators, allows you to invest your HSA funds in some 22 Vanguard mutual funds. Others may offer you only an FDIC-insured saving account (similar to a savings account at your regular institution, but with the ability to contribute pre-tax dollars). Some non-bank companies may provide a savings account—but it’s not FDIC insured. Still others (like Wells Fargo) require a minimum balance of $2,000 before you can invest it.
Know the rules. Because the withdrawal rules vary from traditional plans, you have to keep in mind the specific restrictions that apply to HSAs—and try to stay up to date on changes affecting HSAs under the Affordable Care Act.
Right now, you can withdraw HSA funds tax-free at any point for qualified medical expenses, but if you use them for non-medical expenses, you’ll owe tax on those withdrawals. And if you withdraw money before age 65 for non-medical expenses, you could incur a 20% penalty.
Take the reins. Some HSAs can be set up through your employer, but ultimately you are the owner of the account. You can roll over your current HSA to another provider if you don’t like your employer’s option, says Fronstin. And unlike your 401k, you can take your HSA with you when you leave your job.
An HSA could be a worthy way to supplement your retirement, even if you’ve maxed out your other retirement plans. Because you can max out your 401k and IRA, and still save the full amount permitted in your HSA, it does raise the cap on tax-deferred savings. That said, the fees can be tricky, the investment options are limited, and you’ll only reap the triple tax benefit if you spend the money on medical expenses.
If you have extra cash to invest and haven’t yet maxed out your IRA, do that. Even if you make too much money to deduct it, or you earn too much to contribute to a Roth IRA, consider a non-deductible IRA—which still gives you the benefit of tax-free growth, plus far more control over your investing choices and costs. Betterment’s IRA is free to set up, and our portfolio costs are the lowest in the industry.
Given that the cost of your health care in retirement could be $200,000 or more, according to industry estimates, using an HSA as a tax-advantaged account just for medical bills is smart.
But if you’re looking for a way to supplement your retirement savings in general, an HSA may not be the ideal place to help you money grow. If you use the funds for ordinary, non-medical retirement expenses after age 65, they’ll be taxed at the same rate as IRA withdrawals—but your investment options and the all-in cost could cut into any tax benefits.
Try our IRA Calculator to see which IRA type you qualify for.
Betterment is the largest, fastest-growing automated investing service, helping people to better manage, protect, and grow their wealth through smarter technology. With more than 90,000 customers and over $2 billion in assets under management, the service offers a globally diversified portfolio of ETFs, designed to help provide you with the best possible expected returns for retirement planning, building wealth, and other savings goals. Betterment also helps customers get on track for a comfortable retirement with RetireGuide™, a retirement planning tool that lets people know how much they should save and if they are investing correctly.
This article was last updated on October 6, 2015
Was this article helpful to you?
Our newsletter is full of tips to help you lead a smarter financial life.