Predictably Irrational Behavior
Our stock market experiment results are in. The experiment began with the introduction of a single-stock market. We offered one stock – called FOO – an imaginary up-and-coming tech company.
By the Editorial Staff
Betterment Resource Center |
Published: August 18, 2011
– Everyone starts with $2,000 and 10 shares of FOO.
– FOO produces (randomly generated) dividends between $0 and $20 each round, averaging $10 per round.
– With a total of 15 rounds, a share should be worth $150 (15 rounds x $10).
– As the experiment continues, the stock should be worth less and less – $140 at round 2, $130 at round 3, and $0 at the end.
The game
Round 1 started off slowly, with shares being sold at prices well below their value (Kiran freaked out and sold a share worth $150 for only $18) but as the rounds progressed, the value of the shares began to grow.
By round 3, FOO reached its peak price of $121 per share, just as people began to realize what it was really worth. Those who understood attempted to buy the shares for slightly less than their value, in the hopes that unprepared employees (a.k.a. the software coders) would allow them to buy low and collect the dividends.
Once the trend shifted to buying, share prices rose above their expected value. This is the type of irrational behavior that would normally create a bubble – who pays $95 for a share worth $70?!
The Betterment team, however, was too smart (or too flustered – take your pick) to let the bubble grow. Share prices gradually returned to their expected value, avoiding the “pop” (rapid decrease in price) one usually associates with a bubble.
The results
While some lost money, and some gained, one thing became clear: no matter how smart you think you are, trying to out-smart the market is near impossible. People are predictably irrational. It’s better to set it and forget it.
No surprises that our CEO Jon Stein won the game, with a neat total of $4398.
The above results come from an in-office experiment conducted by Betterment intern Sarah Brock. Thanks Sarah!
Recommended Content
View All Resources
Smart Saver and Other Savings Products: Our Recommendations
We know from talking to Betterment customers that holding cash isn’t always intentional; it’s a choice by default—not knowing how, when, or why to put your money to work. We developed Smart Saver to help with that.
Optimizing Performance in Lower Risk Betterment Portfolios
In this methodology, we provide insight into how we optimize the performance of the lower risk bonds in Betterment's portfolios, including Smart Saver.
10 Financial To-Dos Before Your First Wedding Anniversary
Planning your financial life with your spouse can be very stressful. Here are ten considerations you should talk about before reaching your first anniversary.
Explore your first goal
Safety Net
This is a great place to start—an emergency fund for life's unplanned hiccups. A safety net is a conservative portfolio.
Retirement
Whether it's a long way off or just around the corner, we'll help you save for the retirement you deserve.
General Investing
If you want to invest and build wealth over time, then this is the goal for you. This is an excellent goal type for unknown future needs or money you plan to pass to future generations.
Smart Saver
You could earn 20X more than a typical savings account with our low-risk investing account for your extra cash.